To: The Right Honourable President of the
Supreme Court Hon. Lady Hale.
From: Athinarayanan Sanjeevraja
Date: September 24, 2019
RE: THE UK PRIME MINISTER
Suggestion:
My Lord, let me start my paying my respects to you and through you to. You must
be aware of BREXIT is a serious consequence with so many unforeseen
consequences. IMHO, BREXITERS have no respect for parliamentary democracy and
the rule of law because the UK Parliament can arrive at a BREXIT decision even
if BREXIT has so many unforeseen consequences. If the UK MP’s respected British
democracy then all the UK MP’s would have worked together with the EU
counterpart to deliver an acceptable deal based on the UK-EU Referendum 2016. British
people voted leave the EU but they didn’t vote for No Deal. The Present Prime
Minister of the UK Mr. Boris Johnson think that he is above democracy and the
rule of law and his will is more important than rest of the British. What
happened to the UK Parliament is sovereign? What happened to the 450 years of
evolving the UK Parliamentary democracy? Does the Revolution of 1688 and The
Bloodless Revolution of 1688 is still followed instituting the UK Parliamentary
supremacy and the rule of law? I am sorry to say that the UK Parliament has
disregard of democracy that has set standards for very long time. The UK
Parliamentary democracy where Parliament has been suspended on the advice of
the Prime Minister Mr. Boris Johnson to the QUEEN and that advice is not
accurate or lies then there is no political solution available. This gives the
UK Prime Minister Mr. Boris Johnson has complete control over the UK political
system as Mr. Boris Johnson can suspend Parliament at his will without the
support of the opposition. If I am not mistaken, while Parliament is not
sitting the UK Prime Minister needed to get Parliament to pass a “Bill of
Attainder”. The UK Prime Minister is not a dictator. He cannot make new laws or
increase taxes. He needed to get Parliament to pass “Finance Acts” each year. Yes,
the UK Prime Minister has the power granted him by statute only. I don’t want
to see the UK judges politicised that really attack the essence of the UK democracy.
The honourable Supreme Court knew that the UK constitution relies on various
checks and balances and each player realising that no one can act unilaterally
and no one can act without considering the views of many other players. The
checks and balance of the UK constitution depend on the various players being honest
and plays by the rule of law. It is the essence of the UK democracy. I
fervently hope that honourable Supreme Court has the power to scrutinise and
decide on the constitutionality of the suspension of the Parliament by the UK
Prime Minister. It is time to reinstate impeachment for the UK Parliamentary
supremacy and the rule of law by the UK Prime Minister.
My
Lord, BREXIT has set the EU and the UK against each other. BREXIT has set the
British people against each other. BREXIT has set the UK politicians against
each other. BREXIT has set up no democratic legitimacy in Scotland and Northern
Ireland. BREXIT has set the UK so isolated. BREXIT has set the UK territorial
integrity under pressure. BREXIT has set alienating the UK allies and eroding
all good will. BREXIT has set the courts of the United Kingdom (English Courts,
Scottish Courts and Northern Irish Courts) against each other. BREXIT has set
the constituent countries of the Kingdom against each other. BREXIT has set the
UK constitutional crisis. BREXIT has set the UK political crisis. BREXIT has
set the UK economic crisis. BREXIT has set the UK biggest crisis in decades. BREXIT
has set the Prime Minister drawn in the Queen against convention. This time is
not only to the UK but to the Queen. My Lord, it is going to take very long
time to regain the trust that has been lost because of BREXIT crisis. My Lord,
I most humbly prayed the Honourable Supreme Court is to review the Parliament
suspension against legality of statutory instrument and judge if there has been
violation of parliament suspension. I say with confidence that Mr. Boris
Johnson prorogued Parliament to stop scrutiny of his BREXIT strategy. Mr. Boris
Johnson took drastic steps as No Deal BREXIT without a Parliamentary majority.
There is no majority in the UK Parliament for No Deal BREXIT. No deal is a
minority preference in the UK Parliament as well as British people. When I
wrote to Hon. Theresa May government I insisted that No Deal BREXIT would
result in a state of emergency. This is the greatest constitutional crisis of
the UK.
My
Lord, my argument is that the question of the royal prerogative permits the
Queen to exercise her powers even if the advice is dishonestly given? If it is
normal, Her Majesty’s Government (HMG) needs a Queen speech. If Honourable
Supreme Court judgement to prorogue Parliament is a political issue not a legal
issue, my argument is that the question of whether the Prime Minister’s the
reasons given to the Queen for the advice is true or not must be a legal issue
whatever the subject of the advice. If those reasons were false or not a
legitimate reason the Honourable Supreme Court has evidence that to declare
prorogation Parliament is illegal. I want to see the Honourable Supreme Court
judges to defend their freedoms and institutions while pronouncing the
judgement. I would like to see the honourable Supreme Court judges should stay
away from the Prime Minister’s BREXIT strategy. My Lord, you are the master of
the UK constitution, you must be aware that the royal power of dissolution of
Parliament was abolished by the Fixed Term Parliaments Act 1911, Section 3(2).
Mr. Boris Johnson use of prorogation is to close down the Parliament for six
weeks and for two more weeks than usual autumn recess is an assault of parliamentary
democracy. It has to prevent either Parliamentarians to bring down Mr. Boris
Johnson government in a no confidence vote before BREXIT or primary legislation
taking the matter form the Mr. Boris Johnson hands. In either case, Mr. Boris
Johnson is abusing power of preventing an elected government from fulfilling
its constitutional role about BREXIT. It is also an assault of parliamentary
democracy. This type of constitutional cheating or abusing power does damage to
the reputation of the UK’s constitution and Parliament.
My
Lord, you must be aware that building stable state and stable institutions
takes hundreds of years but to wreck it just need few days. At present, the UK
and institutions remain extremely vulnerable to demagogue take over. Mr. Boris
Johnson and some BREXIT ministers have shown conflict with the Parliamentary
supremacy and the rule of law. My Lord, the UK Parliament has had ample
opportunity to agree on alternative BREXIT deal. I don’t know why it has failed
to do so? The honourable Supreme Court judgement will take the UK constitution
into preserve the UK democracy and maintain the UK’s reputation as a respected
nation at world stage. My Lord, the Scot judges basically said Mr. Boris
Johnson lied before Queen. If the Honourable Supreme Court finds in favour of
the UK Prime Minister, will be a very conflicting political, social and more
fuel for the Scottish, Northern Ireland and perhaps Wales separatists. I firmly
believe that the honourable Supreme Court will be to hold the decision of
Scotland Court to stand for national unity and the defense of the UK
parliamentary democracy.
Thank you very much for your kind attention
My Lord.
Respectfully yours,
Athinarayanan Sanjeevraja
Comments
Post a Comment