Skip to main content

AFGHANISTAN - TALIBAN PEACE DEAL 2020


To:     The Right Honourable Afghanistan President Hon. Ashraf Ghani  

From: Athinarayanan Sanjeevraja

Date: December 8, 2020

RE:     AFGHANISTAN – TALIBAN PEACE TALK 2020

Suggestion: Hon. President, let me start my paying my respects to you and through you to. I wrote to you in the month of September 9, 2019 regarding Afghanistan and Taliban peace talk, I suggested three possible solutions such as one is divide the country into two such as North Afghanistan and South Afghanistan. Give South Afghanistan to Taliban and keep North Afghanistan for your government. Second is power sharing initiative between your government and the Taliban’s. Third is set up western alliances and rule of law institutions to keep peace in Afghanistan. For that you should have a structured government that sought to establish ties with other western nation. Western alliances should provide enough support in all areas and building state, industry, agriculture, educational institutions and financial assistance. I am sure that first and second solutions may be incompatible for you because you may not want to divide the country and the Taliban and your government is incompatible because Taliban culture makes your government pretty much impossible. If any attempt to form a coalition government is destined for failure. I fervently hope that you will choose third solution that will address all issues in Afghanistan. My decision remains the same till today. The tenuous security and prosperity can be achieved if your government established ties with western nations. Please do not forget that your government is on the strong backing of the US and NATO forces.    

Hon. President, Taliban is determined to enforce Islamic law while your government is determined to demand democracy, elections and women’s rights. Both cannot exist in the same place because religious precepts and values are incompatible with democracy. I have many questions in my mind. There are many controversial issues in Afghanistan – Taliban peace talk. Is it possible for Taliban to transform a political party in Afghanistan? Is it possible for Taliban participating democratic process of Afghanistan? Will Taliban allow Afghan people to use social media freely? Humanity will never achieve full human freedom until it rejects religious precepts and values. Will Taliban cuts ties with terrorist groups? Taliban is an armed wing. How will armed wing form a political party or participating democratic process in Afghanistan? I impressed that Taliban were successful in opium eradication in Afghanistan. If I am not wrong, your government also lacks authority. Any peace deal made from government who lacks authority is deeply flawed. In my opinion, a deep analysis is required into Afghanistan-Taliban peace perspective. We need permanent settlement. Temporary settlement will eventually lead to Taliban takeover of Afghanistan sooner than later. How will the ideological position of Afghanistan and Taliban can be reconciled in the long term? For that Afghan people’s ideas and hearts are most important matters for reconciliation process before any other issues.

Thank you very much for your kind attention Hon. President

 

Respectfully yours,

Athinarayanan Sanjeevraja.

Athinarayanan Advisory



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

BRITAIN’S BREXIT BATTLE 2019

To:     The Right Honourable European Commission President Hon. Jean-Claude Juncker   From: Athinarayanan Sanjeevraja Date: August 19, 2019 RE:      BRITAIN’S BREXIT BATTLE   Suggestion: Hon. European Commission President, let me start by paying my respects to you and through you to. The UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson has insisted repeatedly that backstop must go, if not then no deal BREXIT but he support the GFA and custom-free border between the UK (Northern Ireland) and the EU (Republic of Ireland). That is a blatant contradiction. How can he have it both ways? If the UK wanted to exit from the EU bloc without a deal - the return of a hard border is absolutely necessary. Why BREXITERS are object to the backstop? The reason behind that it would give the EU way to keep a toehold in future UK trade policy. If the UK wanted to leave the EU without backstop, in other words, a hard BREXIT or there is been no exit agreement by both the UK and the EU – then the r
Post a Comment
Read more

HONG KONG EXTRADITION BILL 2019

To:     The Right Honourable Chief Executive of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People’s Republic of China Ms. Carrie Lam From: Athinarayanan Sanjeevraja Date: August 29, 2019 RE:      HONG KONG EXTRADITION BILL 2019 Suggestion: Hon. Chief Executive of the Hong Kong let me start by paying my respects to you and through you to. “One Country Two Systems” structure compels Hong Kong to operate currently under different legal system than that of Mainland China. You published the extradition bill on March 29, 2019 and first reading on April 3, 2019 which will destroy Hong Kong legal independence because extradition bill is another attempt for China to take away the Hong Kong independent legal system that China has agreed for Hong Kong to keep until 2047. Thus, the people of Hong Kong marched their protest against the bill on June 9, 2019. Hong Kong protests are still continuing. The silence of your government leads me to believe you have no plan t
Post a Comment
Read more

EU NEW FISCAL AUTHORITY FOR WEAK MEMBER STATES

This paper focuses on setting up new fiscal authority to manage compatible fiscal decentralisation and budgetary discipline in the EU Member States. The authority need to adopt a tough fiscal consolidation programme. The authority should be responsible for designing fiscal policy for all Member States with stricter rules, conscientious monitoring and enforcement mechanisms for the conduct of fiscal decentralisation and budgetary policy. If Member States does not implement or violate the fiscal authority law that Member State/States to be sued in the European Court of Justice. We cannot grow our economy without proper fiscal cooperation between Member States. So the fiscal authority must coach at least weak Member States how to implement effective fiscal policy so that crony driven economy can be turned into a competitive market based economy. EU established the provisions of the Stability and Growth Pact (SGP) to avoid excessive deficits of the Member States and take precise act
Post a Comment
Read more